This page has been automatically translated. Please refer to the page in French if needed.
Disciplinary penalty
Can the personal mobile phone be banned in the workplace?
Publié le 16 novembre 2026 - Public Service / (Prime Minister)
Ms. C. is a maintenance officer in a municipal swimming pool. His superiors gave him a reprimand, in particular because of the use of his mobile phone during his service when it was forbidden for him to do so. It seeks annulment of that decision, taking the view that the memorandum on which the penalty is based is unlawful. Is the sanction against him justified?

In this case, a president of a community of agglomeration pronounces against Ms C., an agent working in a swimming pool, a reprimand, that is to say, a first group disciplinary action.
He accuses him, on the one hand, of having failed in his duty of obedience by using his mobile phone during his service; and on the other hand of having taken breaks outside the ranges provided for in his schedule, by not taking into account the reminders to order of his hierarchy.
Its decision is based in particular on a memo from the pool manager of the agglomeration community concerned. This memo states: « Mobile phone use is prohibited on working time from 8am to 8pm / It will have to stay in your locker room. / Its use is allowed only during the break times appearing on the work schedules. / The notion of personal emergency, incoming or outgoing call, must remain very exceptional and short-lived. Its use must be reported to your manager. In the event of an emergency, you can also tell your family and friends that you can be reached on the workplace line (…) ».
For Ms. C., this memo is illegal, so is the sanction against her. And it is not proportionate to the seriousness of the facts alleged against it. The agent seeks the annulment of the penalty and a payment of EUR 2 000 from the agglomeration community in respect of the costs incurred.
Can it obtain the annulment of the penalty imposed on it?
Public Service replies:
The administrative court of Toulouse has ruled that the rules established by the agglomeration community are intended to ensure the concentration of security and maintenance staff working in swimming pools. It considers that they do not hinder individual freedom because they are not general and absolute ; the use of the mobile phone is allowed during rest periods and in case of personal emergency.
For the court, the note is legal because of its measured nature and can serve as a basis for the sanction imposed on the complainant.
The officer was seen using her mobile phone during her working hours, and was on break twice outside of her scheduled hours. These established facts, which violate the rules of work organization defined by the employer and the repeated instructions of his hierarchy, constitute disciplinary misconduct.
The Administrative Court considered that, in issuing a reprimand, the President of the agglomeration community did not take a disproportionate penalty. Mrs C.'s application is rejected and she must pay the agglomeration community a sum of EUR 500 in respect of the costs incurred.
Agenda
Du 21 nov. au 27 nov. 2026
Départ à la retraite
Publié le 16 novembre 2026
À partir du 20 nov. 2026
Consommation
Publié le 12 novembre 2026
À partir du 1 nov. 2026
Sécurité routière
Publié le 20 octobre 2026